Abe's Pizza

Enjoy delicious, authentic pizza at Abe's Pizza in Monticello, IN. Savor breadsticks, buffalo chicken ranch, deep dish, and thin crust options, plus salads, sandwiches, and barbecue chicken. Order now for fast, accurate service!

Welcome to Abe's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza

Nestled at 234 N Main St in Monticello, Abe's Pizza offers a slice of comfort food goodness that invites both locals and visitors to indulge in their pizza cravings. From the moment you walk through the door, the smell of freshly baked breadsticks and savory toppings fills the air. This charming spot is where community and food intersect, making it a favorite for families and friends looking to enjoy a casual meal together. Offering a diverse menu—from traditional thin crust to hearty deep dish—Abe's ensures everyone finds something to enjoy.

Whether dining in or enjoying takeout, this establishment provides an authentic pizza experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. Plus, the friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making each visit feel like a homecoming.

Location & Contact

Address

234 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, United States

Phone

+1 574-583-9600

Social Media

About

Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza
Abe's Pizza

Abe's Pizza stands out in Monticello not only for its delicious offerings but also for its commitment to community and quality. Founded by pizza enthusiasts, this local eatery began as a small establishment with a vision to bring exquisite pizza to the heart of the town. Over the years, it has evolved into a beloved gathering spot, showcasing the importance of community ties in its growth.

The owners prioritize the use of fresh ingredients sourced from local suppliers, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor. Not only does this practice support local businesses, but it also enhances the freshness of the dishes served. Each recipe reflects classic pizza-making traditions while embracing modern tastes. Their buffalo chicken ranch and barbecue chicken pizzas illustrate this perfect blend of old and new. Furthermore, Abe's is not just about pizza; other menu items like hand-breaded mozzarella sticks and chicken soup showcase the variety available, making it an all-around choice for those dining out.

The restaurant frequently hosts community events, creating a family-friendly vibe that resonates with guests. Regular patrons often gather here, forming friendships rooted in shared meals and experiences. The diverse clientele highlights Abe's ability to bring people together, turning casual dinners into memorable gatherings.

Work Hours

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Abe's Pizza shines with its diverse menu, highlighting six standout dishes that cater to every taste. Breadsticks serve as a perfect appetizer, paired with marinara or enjoyed solo. The buffalo chicken ranch pizza combines the right amount of spice with creamy ranch, offering a unique twist on a classic favorite. For pizza purists, traditional pepperoni and cheese options never disappoint. Those craving something hearty can indulge in the deep-dish pizza, known for its layers of flavor.

For something lighter, salads and sandwiches are also on the menu, allowing more health-conscious diners a chance to enjoy a fulfilling meal. The emphasis on order accuracy ensures that each pizza arrives just as envisioned, reducing wait times and enhancing customer satisfaction.

Abe's Pizza

The exterior of Abe's Pizza reflects its welcoming spirit. The cozy brick facade blends seamlessly with the quaint Monticello landscape. Large windows invite passersby to catch a glimpse of the lively atmosphere within. Outdoor seating options add to the charm, allowing guests to bask in the sun during warmer months while enjoying their favorite dishes. The casual vibe complements the laid-back dining experience that Abe's offers. Friendly conversations often fill the air, echoing the laughter of gathered friends and families. This mix of comfort and community makes Abe's a go-to spot for both quick bites and leisurely dining experiences.

Customer Reviews

Nice people running the place. Good pizza. A great home town pizza joint.

J
Joshua L.

My sister and I decided to stop for lunch. Ordered a 14 in cheese pizza, thin crust. It was absolutely delicious! The crust was nice and crunchy, but not burnt. Priced right. I believe Shirley was our waitress. Such a sweetheart. Abe's was also very well kept. I'll definitely stop in again when I'm in the area.

d
dona s.

Stopped in town for the night. Kids wanted pizza. Grabbed a large za and some bread sticks. Lemme tell yah; the diner is so cute, the service was perfect, and the food was delicious! Thanks for dinner yall :)

J
Jennifer O.

We live in Rensselaer and go to Monticello a couple times a year. We always go to Abe's and it is consistently GOOD! This year we have made many trips and absolutely think this is the best pizza around. Sweet "Shirley" our waitress is one of a kind and you just gotta love her. This place is the best and will return many more times in the future... Try it and you will be back......Promise:-)

R
Rich S.

Cozy setting. Pizza is made to order. Thin, hand rolled, deep dish. We liked the Italian sausage the best. We tried both hand rolled and thin, both were good. Next week we will try the deep dish. Oh yeah the bread sticks with garlic butter, they were great.

T
Tony A.

Awesome pizza am glad you guys deliver if I ever come back to this town to get another load am calling you guys.

J
John K.